Things have come a long way over the years. No story illustrates that more clearly than the tale of Wesley May, Frank Hawks and Earl Daugherty who together achieved the world’s first aerial refueling by manually transferring gasoline from one plane to another in 1921. While undoubtedly most would think that the first refueling was accomplished by the US Army Air Corps via its experiments with the “Question Mark”, that would be wrong. That aircraft was a highly modified Atlantic-Fokker C-2A that was refueled by a Douglas C-1 and it managed a record-setting 150 hours in the air over the first week of January 1929 — yet that was eight years after the 1921 daring deed of the three men. So just how was it done? Well, first you strap a 5 gallon gas can onto your back….
The Planned Aerial Refueling Attempt
Wesley “Wes” May, Frank Hawks and Earl Daugherty had a simple plan. First, Wes would strap the gas can onto his back. Then he would join Frank in the passenger seat of his Lincoln Standard biplane and the two would take off. Earl Daugherty would likewise take off in his Curtiss Jenny. Once airborne and at an altitude of around 1,000 feet, Earl would carefully approach the Lincoln Standard while Wes climbed atop the wing and worked his way out to the right wingtip. Then, as they had done at barnstorming events previously, Earl would come close enough and above the Lincoln Standard for Wes to grab hold of the bottom left wing’s under wing strut on the Curtiss Jenny. With luck, the three men considered, Wes would then pull himself up onto the lower wing, grab the struts and wires and, as Earl and Frank gently banked away from each other, he would work his way to the front passenger cockpit of the Curtiss Jenny. In this way, the fuel could be transferred from one plane to another. As Wes was a skilled stuntman and wing walker, he considered the transfer well within his skills and abilities.
The idea was that once in the Jenny’s cockpit, Wes would have access to the fuel tank that was located behind the engine. Thus, Wes would carefully undo the fuel tank’s cap, then set up the gas can spout to enable him to pour the contents in. Then, being careful to avoid the gas blowing off, he would pour the 5 gallons into the Jenny’s gas tank before sitting down in the cockpit and strapping in. After that, all that was needed was just a routine landing. To ensure that the stunt was captured for all posterity, the three also planned to have a chase plane fly behind and take a photograph of the stunt as Wes climbed from one plane to another.
The Achievement and What Followed
As it happened, the plan was almost perfectly executed. In fact, the only problem encountered was that it took a lot longer than was expected to get the gas poured into the Curtiss Jenny’s gas tank! The transfer from one plane to another wasn’t that difficult, though Wes had a bit of a harder time of it than the usual simply because he was carrying another 30 pounds of dead weight on his back in the form of fuel. That required a bit more strength than it usually took to pull himself up onto the Jenny’s lower wing, but in the end, he managed it. If you’ve ever done chin-ups or pulled yourself up on a set of monkey bars, you know how this works — then consider how much more challenging it would be to put 30 pounds of weight on your back!
With the success of the operation, two things became apparent. First, aerial fuel transfers were clearly demonstrated to be possible. Second, it was equally apparent that the method taken by Wes, Frank and Earl was more than a little impractical. It relied on wing walking skills that were somewhat rare and considered to be the stuff of daredevil barnstormers, rather than professional aviators in military or commercial employment. Additionally, the amount of fuel transferred was minimal. As well, the transfer could be accomplished at the slow speeds that both the Curtiss Jenny and Lincoln Standard could together muster. Therefore, at best the first aerial refueling was little more than a stunt — but then again, who could blame the three men for trying it. They were barnstormers after all!
Later Efforts and the Breakthroughs that Resulted
The US Army Air Service didn’t wait another eight years to try out aerial refueling with the “Question Mark”. In fact, just a year and a half after the 1921 barnstorming trick, the Army did it more properly with two Airco DH-4B biplanes. One, the refueling aircraft, was flown by First Lieutenant Virgil Hine while First Lieutenant Frank Seifert gently released a fueling hose backward into the wind. A second Airco DH-4B biplane, flown by Captain Lowell Smith, approached from below and behind while Lieutenant John Richter, sitting in the second seat, grabbed hold of the flapping hose and affixed it to the top of the fuel tank. Once accomplished, he signaled to First Lieut. Seifert to start transferring fuel. In this way, on June 27, 1923, the two planes achieved the feat of a more proper aerial refueling.
Just two months later, on August 27 and 28, 1923, the US Army Air Service did it again, this time using three Airco DH-4Bs in a record setting attempt for aerial endurance. One plane would remain aloft and continuously fly while the other two planes (both “tankers” in modern parlance) flew alongside in shifts to transfer fuel and engine oil. As it happened, they managed 37 hours of flight time in the record-setting plane, though it required nine aerial refueling efforts during which 687 gallons of gas and 38 gallons of engine oil were transferred (such early planes bled off engine oil out of the exhaust of their radial engines at a rate of about a gallon an hour!).
Aerial Refueling Today
From such humble beginnings, aerial refueling has become the key enabling factor of military air power. Without it, the ability to hit targets anywhere in the world would be nearly impossible. Another key benefit of aerial refueling is that fighter-bombers are able to take off with heavier loads and far less fuel, by then “tanking up” once at altitude. This way, modern aircraft can take off with weapons loads that far exceed what was once possible. Likewise, cargo aircraft can lift off with extraordinary loads and tank up while en route — for every pound of fuel that can be saved at take off, more cargo or weapons can be lifted off into the air.
Today’s military air forces are entirely dependent on aerial refueling, yet commercial aviation never would commonly utilize aerial refueling techniques. Instead, long haul, wide body jets would develop high efficiency engine technologies and great thrust so as to be able to link distant city pairs non-stop. As a result, one can buy a ticket these days for routine, regularly scheduled flights from Los Angeles to Hong Kong non-stop, as but one example of such capabilities. In any case, is air-to-air refueling even necessary for commercial airliners? After all, at some point the passengers are simply exhausted and need to spend some time on the ground anyway. Would you want to fly in coach seating for more than 17 hours in the back of a modern 747?